Specification → evidence

Evidence map

Clause pages follow the headings in EVIDENCE-MAP.md. Where the source map reports no empirical evidence, conformance and efficacy remain separate.

Publication evidence status
  • B1 · resolved · Official-export verification of captured grade IDs: All 5,020 captured graded IDs now match unique rows in the refreshed public official grade export by exact cell ID. The 128 post-cut rows were appended from the authoritative ledger; 25 invalid control_apply rows are controls, not model failures. Evidence source.
  • B2 · resolved · Pinned Kogen specification snapshot and clause anchors: The locally sanitized v1.2 snapshot preserves cited content from original revision 1118f7fc0dbb042af8c8de2ffd1b85768cf9e2a0 and uses public-release sanitization revision 30d9b25e4eefa7117121de44298fed504b429f4e. Its published-byte SHA-256 manifest verifies, and all 134 pinned EVIDENCE-MAP fragments resolve locally. The decision ledger is absent, so comprehensive decision-to-clause coverage remains limited. Evidence source.
Read the publication validation report
Map the clause, then inspect the recordEach clause links to explicit hypothesis IDs, round receipts, and claim-ledger rows found in the authored map. No missing claim is inferred.

Evidence map caveats · EVIDENCE-MAP.md

Reviewed 2026-10-07. This map connects the spec clause inventory in the publication plan to the public benchmark record. It records what the current data can support and the measurement still needed. An implementation or conformance result shows parity with a stated contract; it does not show that the contract improves Build success.

Reading this map

  • Empirical means a claim about measured outcomes. The analysis status is shown beside each cited record.
  • Normative product means a product rule or choice. It may be a current design decision without a comparative result.
  • Safety/correctness means a behavior required for containment, integrity, or reliable state transitions. Conformance establishes implementation parity only.
  • Implementation freedom means the spec leaves the implementation choice open or deferred.
  • Claim IDs refer to `results/claim-ledger.jsonl`. A row with status INTERIM, CONFOUNDED, WITHDRAWN, or NOT-RUN is not evidence of measured superiority.

The evidence map uses a locally sanitized v1.2 clause-reference snapshot in spec/. Its original cited content revision is 1118f7fc0dbb042af8c8de2ffd1b85768cf9e2a0; the upstream public sanitization revision is 30d9b25e4eefa7117121de44298fed504b429f4e. spec/SOURCE.json records original source hashes separately from SHA-256 hashes of the published bytes. All 134 pinned v1.2 fragments linked below are locally verified against that snapshot. The decision ledger is absent, so comprehensive decision-to-clause coverage remains limited and cannot be independently verified.

Decision coverage caveat · EVIDENCE-MAP.md

Decision-ID coverage

Every v1.2 clause fragment linked above is locally verified against the published snapshot. The source classification's section-level D references are present, but the underlying decision ledger is absent, so comprehensive decision-to-clause coverage remains limited and cannot be independently verified. Product decisions with no measured claim should retain an explicit NORMATIVE or NO EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE label.