Evidence map clause
3.0 Rules
This clause and its evidence summary follow the authored EVIDENCE-MAP.md section.
Evidence map clause · EVIDENCE-MAP.md
Map clause: Shaping, approval, and witness.
Source heading anchors: spec/03-build.md#30-rules; spec/03-build.md#32-shaping-intent-shape; spec/03-build.md#321-conversations; spec/03-build.md#322-pre-steps; spec/03-build.md#323-validation-each-pass-in-order; spec/03-build.md#324-repair-message-exact; spec/03-build.md#325-results; spec/03-build.md#326-concerns-and-progress; spec/03-build.md#327-witness-path-target-contract-pending-measurement; spec/03-build.md#328-assumption-recheck; spec/03-build.md#33-approval-checks
Spec revision / decision reference: v1.2 (pinned fragment locally verified); section-level D references are listed in the source classification. Last reviewed: 2026-10-07.
Type: Normative product for the phase boundary; empirical for shaping and witness effects; safety/correctness for approval enforcement.
Evidence and status: R69 and R71 are INTERIM; R73 is NOT-RUN. Offline coverage, over-strict, and candidate records carry INTERIM claims:
CL-WA-intent-coverage-audit-reported-observation,CL-WA-overstrict-replay-reported-observation, andCL-WA-candidate-counterfactual-reported-observation. The records do not establish a Build guarantee or a causal shaping effect. Related hypotheses: H01–H15, H75, H87, H117–H124, H140–H144.Unresolved measurement: A registered same-task comparison of shaped and unshaped Intents with exact ITT denominators; a separate prospective witness study measuring post-approval failure, end-to-end completion, and witness cost.