Evidence map clause

3.1 The recipe: ladder

This clause and its evidence summary follow the authored EVIDENCE-MAP.md section.

Source-reported map entryRead the linked round, hypothesis, and claim records for the current status and limits. A normative or conformance statement is not an efficacy result.

Evidence map clause · EVIDENCE-MAP.md

Map clause: Ladder, rungs, retries, and completion.

  • Source heading anchors: spec/03-build.md#31-the-recipe-ladder; spec/03-build.md#34-build-orchestration; spec/03-build.md#35-the-rung-machine; spec/03-build.md#36-developer-messages

  • Spec revision / decision reference: v1.2 (pinned fragment locally verified); section-level D references are listed in the source classification. Last reviewed: 2026-10-07.

  • Type: Empirical for model, effort, ladder, retry, and cost claims; normative product for budgets and route rules.

  • Evidence and status: R49, R49b, R53, R56, R64, R65, R65b, R66, R68b, R72, R74, and hc-1–hc-4 retain separate cohorts. R49, R49b, R65, R65b, and hc-1–hc-4 are INTERIM; R68b is CONFOUNDED; CL-WA-r53-public-export-coverage, CL-WA-r56-public-export-coverage, CL-WA-r64-public-export-coverage, CL-WA-r69-public-export-coverage, CL-WA-r70-public-export-coverage, and CL-WA-r71-public-export-coverage are INTERIM; CL-WA-r72-lifecycle-and-outcome is INTERIM; R74 is WITHDRAWN (CL-WA-r74-public-export-coverage, WITHDRAWN). Historical comparison summaries CL-H111-historical-staged-and-direct-comparison and CL-H112-historical-route-cost-frontier are INTERIM, `source-reported, not reproducible from public data**. These statuses do not support a pooled ladder or superiority claim. Related hypotheses: H39–H50, H75–H90, H111–H116, H129, H131–H139, H143.

  • Unresolved measurement: A closed, current-version, same-model comparison of direct and staged routes with exact tasks, effort, effective settings, ITT, cost semantics, and predeclared stopping and analysis rules.