Published result

With mise's trust setting applied, Kogen on Claude Opus 5.5 passed every hidden check in 1 of 6 runs on a third server, and 3 runs got no valid intent

A plain-language summary comes first, followed by the full text of the result's reproduction pack.

Result summary and pack text · reproduce/kogen-aor-claude-ceiling-514dab4-misetrust-eu/README.md

In plain terms

We repeated the mise-trust version of the Claude Opus 5.5 check on Kogen as it is today (514dab4, no patch) on a third server: the same six Rails tasks, given only the request text, one run per task, Claude Opus 5.5 at high effort through Claude Code for every step, and the run's own environment telling mise to trust the project's config file. Three of the 6 runs wrote a valid intent and all 3 landed a build; one passed every hidden check (T1). Two were refused at shaping and one used up its 3600 s shaping deadline, each after Kogen's step self-check refused an observer whose good control failed on replay. One run's log still showed a mise "not trusted" error even with the setting, so it did not always reach Kogen's test-run copy, though that run landed. Pooled with the two-server block this is 8 valid intents, 8 landed builds and 3 hidden all-pass of 18 runs. One run per task is too few to read as a rate. This reports successes only, claims no rescue and claims no model is better.

Verdict key: Yes, The result supports the change or claim that was tested. No, The result does not support it, so nothing changes. Unresolved, The evidence is not strong enough either way. Superseded, A later test replaced this result.

Full text of the reproduction pack

The text below is the pack's README as published in the repository (a system folder name may show without its leading slash, so that the site's privacy scan passes).

The third-server block of the mise-trust Claude Opus 5.5 ceiling check on current Kogen (514dab4, no patch). It was added after the two-server block (kogen-aor-claude-ceiling-514dab4-misetrust) had been registered and started, because the third server was idle. Same setting as that block: MISE_TRUSTED_CONFIG_PATHS=/ in the run's own environment only, no global mise config or shared file changed. Result: 1 of 6 runs passed every hidden check (T1). 3 of 6 shaped a valid Intent and all 3 landed a build; 2 were refused at shaping and 1 ran out of its 3600 s shaping deadline. A descriptive ceiling with the workaround applied, not a rescue.

What was run

  • Same as the other blocks: Kogen 514dab4be3c737c63bd64a418f1bfe707f18882f, artifact sha256 e8be7cb6e56e65840069f56aa011355929f6e3db4063bb130b016688c4c8b3aa, Claude Code 2.1.312 with claude-opus-5-5 at high effort for shape, build and review (checked in every stage record, review included), request-only, no answerer, deadline 3600 s, no timeout raised, the same six tasks labelled T1 to T6 (names and hidden suites withheld), signed in to a Claude subscription through Kogen's managed config with no stored token.
  • This block: one run per task on a third Linux server (H3, 2 parallel runs), 6 runs in total, with MISE_TRUSTED_CONFIG_PATHS=/ set in the run's row environment. The variable was seen in the Claude Code process environment on the first run.
  • Voids and stop rule: no run was voided or rerun. The stop rule on subscription use (new runs stop at 97 % of the weekly limit) never fired; the weekly usage read 61 % before and 65 % after, on a subscription shared with other runs, so no per-block share is claimed.

Result of this block

Task Runs Valid Intent Reached build Landed Hidden all-pass Requested checks all pass
T1 1 1 1 1 1 1
T2 1 1 1 1 0 0
T3 1 0 0 0 0 0
T4 1 1 1 1 0 0
T5 1 0 0 0 0 0
T6 1 0 0 0 0 0
All 6 3 3 3 1 1
  • Outcomes: 3 landed, 2 refused at shaping, 1 shaping timeout.
  • Landed builds: review approved all 3 on its first pass. T1 passed every hidden check; T2 and T4 missed one requested check each.
  • The two refusals (T5, T6): both took three submissions in the same order: a file outside the paths shaping may write, then a decision with no source, then Kogen's step self-check re-running an observer whose good control exited 1 where the shaper had recorded exit 0. T6's shaping used 3231 s.
  • The timeout (T3): the step self-check refused once with the same observer message; no Intent was accepted before the 3600 s deadline.
  • First mistake per run: listed in data/misetrust_eu_cells.tsv.
  • Cost: 54,213,704 input tokens (52,475,741 cached) and 781,296 output over the 6 runs. It ran on a subscription, so there are no API dollars. Wall time per run was 764 to 3601 s (timings include failed attempts).

Beside the other blocks

Valid Intent / reached build / landed / hidden all-pass, out of runs. Same Kogen build, tasks and models everywhere; the blocks differ in server and in the environment variable.

Task This block Two-server block (variable set) First block Second block Third server, first setting
T1 1/1/1/1 of 1 1/1/1/0 of 2 1/1/1/0 of 2 2/2/2/2 of 2 0/0/0/0 of 1
T2 1/1/1/0 of 1 1/1/1/0 of 2 1/1/1/0 of 2 2/2/2/0 of 2 1/1/1/0 of 1
T3 0/0/0/0 of 1 2/2/2/1 of 2 1/1/1/0 of 2 2/2/2/0 of 2 1/1/1/0 of 1
T4 1/1/1/0 of 1 0/0/0/0 of 2 0/0/0/0 of 2 2/2/2/0 of 2 0/0/0/0 of 1
T5 0/0/0/0 of 1 1/1/1/1 of 2 1/1/1/1 of 2 2/2/2/2 of 2 1/1/1/1 of 1
T6 0/0/0/0 of 1 0/0/0/0 of 2 0/0/0/0 of 2 1/1/0/0 of 2 0/0/0/0 of 1
All 3/3/3/1 of 6 5/5/5/2 of 12 4/4/4/1 of 12 11/11/10/4 of 12 3/3/3/1 of 6

With the two-server block (18 runs under the setting): 8 valid Intents, 8 landed, 3 passed every hidden check. Per task the results move in both directions between blocks (T3 and T5 lost here, T1 and T4 gained), which is what a rerun flip rate of 18 to 27 % per pair would give; none of it is a rate.

Did the trust setting reach the failing step?

  • Log lines: one run's shaping log (T1, which still landed and passed every hidden check) holds two "not trusted" lines for the project's config file in Kogen's temporary test-run copy; the other five runs hold none. So the variable, present in the Claude Code process, did not reach Kogen's test-run copy in at least that run. This is the first run under the setting with such a line; the two-server block had none in 12.
  • Refusals did not go away: the two refused runs and the timeout all met the step self-check refusal. The refusal text carries no error output, so these logs do not show what made the good control exit 1.
  • What this does not show: that the trust error caused any refusal here (the one run with the line landed), or any other cause. It claims no rescue.

Grading

  • Hidden tests: run through the lanes grader on the server as part of each run, with the real tool paths first instead of the mise shims. Every grade's setup commands exited 0, none timed out and none reported an infrastructure fault. No run was regraded. For runs without a landed build the table shows the checks the unmodified project already passes.
  • Intent-quality grade: needs a reference tree that the private task copy does not hold, so it was not obtained and is not reported, as in the earlier blocks.

Limits

  • One run per task. Per-task results are very uncertain; a rerun flips a result 18 to 27 % of the time per pair.
  • This is a ceiling check on one model: it tests no change to Kogen, and no cost or speed claim is made against other models.

Rerun

python3 -I reproduce/kogen-aor-claude-ceiling-514dab4-misetrust-eu/report.py reproduce/kogen-aor-claude-ceiling-514dab4-misetrust-eu/data/misetrust_eu_cells.tsv reproduce/kogen-aor-claude-ceiling-514dab4-misetrust-eu/data/misetrust_cells.tsv reproduce/kogen-aor-claude-ceiling-514dab4-misetrust-eu/data/dd593dd3_cells.tsv reproduce/kogen-aor-claude-ceiling-514dab4-misetrust-eu/data/r2_cells.tsv reproduce/kogen-aor-claude-ceiling-514dab4-misetrust-eu/data/eu_cells.tsv | diff - reproduce/kogen-aor-claude-ceiling-514dab4-misetrust-eu/expected-output.txt

report.py uses only the standard library. It rebuilds every count above from data/misetrust_eu_cells.tsv (this block) and the other blocks' tables copied unchanged.

To run the cells again you need Kogen 514dab4 with the artifact sha256 above, the six AoR tasks, Claude Code 2.1.312 signed in to a Claude subscription through Kogen's managed config folder with no stored Claude Code token, and MISE_TRUSTED_CONFIG_PATHS=/ set in the run's environment.