Comparison

Kogen shaping component

Results about the step that turns a request into an agreed specification with executable acceptance checks, each measured against Kogen's own earlier behaviour.

Comparison · site/content/finding-pages.json

Results about the step that turns a request into an agreed specification with executable acceptance checks, each measured against Kogen's own earlier behaviour.

Results, newest first

Result Verdict Finished
Setup evidence in contract review remains unproven Unresolved 8 November 2026
Historical and current shaping releases Unresolved 8 November 2026
Screen of shaping evidence and probe handling No 8 November 2026
Evidence-path guidance before and after rejection No 8 November 2026
Decision check and shaping readiness Unresolved 8 November 2026
Combined evidence and transient-output guidance No 8 November 2026
Guidance for carrying shaping decisions No 8 November 2026
Variation in shaping readiness Unresolved 8 November 2026
Shaping guidance for assumptions and evidence No 8 November 2026
Existing-behavior evidence in shaping No 7 November 2026
Initial evidence-path instruction in shaping No 7 November 2026
Evidence-path instructions in shaping No 7 November 2026
Deciding instead of asking shortens shaping's question loop but does not produce Intents No 7 November 2026
Shaping readiness on a fixed request set Unresolved 7 November 2026
Preventing transient bytecode in shaping checks No 7 November 2026
Variation in shaping readiness Unresolved 7 November 2026
Naming the decision line and controls.json gets Rails shapes through shaping Yes 7 November 2026
Naming the gate forms in the shaper prompt gets small requests through shaping; the Rails tasks stop at later gates No 6 November 2026
The review-size bound counts whole files the review never carries, and the one change that passes it removes the gate No 6 November 2026
The decision-record gate costs one shaping attempt, but other gates end these shapes before readiness No 6 November 2026
The second shaper text changes leave all six cells at the 30-minute deadline, with the first draft using most of it Unresolved 6 November 2026
The shaper prompt change gets one of five refused tasks to readiness; the rest stop at prose statements and later gates No 6 November 2026
Request-only shaping refusals are mostly prompt-versus-gate contradictions, and gate-side changes alone turn 2 of 5 No 6 November 2026
Handoff questions stopped shaping before the question check, not after No 5 November 2026
A model-free scope inventory names every owner-keyed store the hidden checks touch; the counted shaper cells were not run Unresolved 5 November 2026
Static checks on shaped files stop 1 of 22 defects the builder refuses No 5 November 2026
Shaping recovery on Claude: one rescue, otherwise a tie (tentative) Unresolved 5 November 2026
Shaping recovery on Claude: second smoke run, unresolved Unresolved 5 November 2026
Bounded shaping recovery confirmation Unresolved 4 November 2026
Repair after shaping refusals remains tentative Unresolved 4 November 2026