> Data revision: baf7c2f4307d3a989a8fb9363df8000fda3d9310
> Source files:
- [results/claim-ledger.jsonl](https://github.com/KogenAI/kogen-bench/blob/baf7c2f4307d3a989a8fb9363df8000fda3d9310/results/claim-ledger.jsonl)

# CL-WA-r74-source-reported-denominator-variants

**Source:** `results/claim-ledger.jsonl`  
**Ledger status:** WITHDRAWN  
**Evidence status:** Reproducible from public L0 reconciliation CSVs for the recovered 167 internal scored rows, 9 smoke attempts, and coverage counts. These rows are not independently joined to the canonical official outcome export; 231 retained slots lack recovered cell IDs and terminal statuses. WITHDRAWN. 231 retained slots remain source-reported, not reproducible from public data.

Values below are transcribed from this claim-ledger entry. The site does not recalculate them. A status such as INTERIM, CONFOUNDED, or WITHDRAWN is not a validated advantage.

## Claim fields

- **metric:** `"historical_denominator_conflict"`
- **numerator:** `null`
- **denominator:** `null`
- **unit:** `null`
- **comparison:** `null`
- **analysis_rule:** `"Keep historical source denominators separate from public export counts and from adjacent amendments or replications."`
- **evidence_status:** `"Reproducible from public L0 reconciliation CSVs for the recovered 167 internal scored rows, 9 smoke attempts, and coverage counts. These rows are not independently joined to the canonical official outcome export; 231 retained slots lack recovered cell IDs and terminal statuses. WITHDRAWN. 231 retained slots remain source-reported, not reproducible from public data."`
- **claim_status:** `"WITHDRAWN"`
- **publication_status:** `"RECONCILIATION_QUEUE"`
- **reported_values:** `{"initial_n": 480, "public_capture_n": 0, "public_official_rows_n": 0, "removed_unstarted_n": 82, "retained_n": 398, "snapshot_run_record_n": 176, "snapshot_scored_graded_n": 167}`
- **interpretation:** `"The L0 CSVs reproduce the selected internal snapshot counts, but the retained cohort remains incomplete and has no public scored outcome join. Preserve WITHDRAWN; do not use the recovered subset as an efficacy estimate."`
- **reconciliation_status:** `"Public L0 CSV analysis is reproducible; official outcome join status remains explicitly scoped in evidence_status."`
- **denominator_variants:** `[{"evidence_status": "reproducible from public L0 coverage CSV; source provenance remains reported", "n": 480, "population": "initial_n", "source_status": "reproducible from public L0 coverage CSV; source provenance remains reported"}, {"evidence_status": "reproducible from public L0 coverage CSV; source provenance remains reported", "n": 82, "population": "removed_unstarted_n", "source_status": "reproducible from public L0 coverage CSV; source provenance remains reported"}, {"evidence_status": "reproducible from public L0 coverage CSV; source provenance remains reported", "n": 398, "population": "retained_n", "source_status": "reproducible from public L0 coverage CSV; source provenance remains reported"}, {"evidence_status": "reproducible from public L0 CSV; not independently joined to canonical official outcome export", "n": 167, "population": "snapshot_scored_graded_n", "source_status": "reproducible from public L0 CSV; not independently joined to canonical official outcome export"}, {"evidence_status": "reproducible from public L0 coverage CSV; source provenance remains reported", "n": 176, "population": "snapshot_run_record_n", "source_status": "reproducible from public L0 coverage CSV; source provenance remains reported"}, {"evidence_status": "reproducible from public L0 coverage CSV; no tagged public outcome rows", "n": 0, "population": "public_capture_n", "source_status": "reproducible from public L0 coverage CSV; no tagged public outcome rows"}, {"evidence_status": "reproducible from public L0 coverage CSV; no tagged public outcome rows", "n": 0, "population": "public_official_rows_n", "source_status": "reproducible from public L0 coverage CSV; no tagged public outcome rows"}]`
- **evidence:** `[{"path": "rounds/r74/README.md", "selector": "status and source reconciliation note"}, {"reproducibility": "source-reported, not reproducible from public data", "source": "research synthesis summary"}, {"path": "rounds/l0-reconcile/data/r74-graded-subset.csv", "selector": "167 recovered internal scored-grade rows"}, {"path": "rounds/l0-reconcile/data/r74-smoke-attempts.csv", "selector": "9 smoke attempt grade rows"}, {"path": "rounds/l0-reconcile/data/r74-coverage.csv", "selector": "retained, missing, and public-export counts"}, {"path": "reproduce/reconcile_l0.py", "selector": "r74()"}]`

## Population references

Round: [r74](/rounds/r74/)

### Related experiments

- [r74](/rounds/r74/)
The ledger does not provide exact cell IDs for this claim.
